Cases and evidence

Contrary opinions exist, but nobody can stop the proposal. Do you approve the next major investment?

Current product policyLast updated September 30, 2026

07Capital governance

RWE decision governance

Contrary opinions exist, but nobody can stop the proposal. Do you approve the next major investment?

Decision owner：Board / capital committee

Verified analysis summary
What you are being asked to decideMore than €10 billion had been committed while major proposals shared the same rising-price assumptions.
Cost of getting it wrongA red team becomes ceremony while the same price assumptions keep driving billions in commitments.
Marcus · DecisionChoose the stop right before choosing another review method.
Evelyn · Evidence & riskThe common rising-price assumption creates correlated risk across proposals.
Sofia · Stakeholder impactWithout pause authority, dissent is documented but cannot protect capital.
Minerva Team's provisional judgmentA red team or reversal rule becomes a ritual unless someone can actually pause or change the proposal when contrary evidence appears.

Set the capital threshold, pilot one bounded challenge process on the next proposal, and name who can pause it.

The question only you can resolveWho has explicit authority to pause the proposal when the reversal evidence appears?
See why the Minerva Team reached this judgment

Selected methodsRoot-cause analysis + option comparison

What would reverse itIf neither pilot connects contrary evidence to real pause authority, define the stop right before choosing a review method.

Official public sourceMcKinsey & Company · RWE decision-process interview

Analysis work receipt

1official source6model calls10/10decision checks125.7actual runtime

What this proves—and what it does not

These are independent teaching simulations, not real correspondence or customer outcomes. Minerva Advisor is not affiliated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, certified by, or reviewed by Minerva University, Minerva Project, McKinsey & Company, or any organization described in a source article. A passed case proves compliance with its versioned decision-quality contract only; it does not prove ROI or the source article's outcome.

Independent teaching simulation. The named consulting firm supplied the public source only; it did not use, review, endorse, sponsor, certify or commission Minerva Advisor. This evidence does not claim customer results, ROI or a permanent service-level guarantee.

All cases and validation →

MINERVA DECISION READINESS REVIEW

Bring one decision you cannot afford to guess.

Minerva separates evidence, inference and unknowns, then shows options, the strongest objection and what would reverse the recommendation.

Start a Minerva Decision Readiness Review

Bring a real, de-identified decision. Google sign-in and product access are required; your plan and Decision Credits apply. You remain the decision-maker, and no email or external action is sent automatically.